Know thyself: Your edge in smarter investing

If two people experience the same market event, their reactions can be wildly different. One sees opportunity; the other feels danger. One shrugs off volatility; another checks their balance three times a day. These aren’t differences in intelligence or experience. They are differences in financial personality – the stable patterns in how each of us thinks, feels and behaves around money.

Understanding this part of yourself is one of the most powerful investing tools you can develop. Markets will always move unpredictably, but your behaviour need not. And the more self-aware you are, the more consistently you will follow the long-term plan you set for yourself.

What financial personality really means

Financial personality is not about being “good” or “bad” with money. It reflects your natural tendencies: how you respond to uncertainty, how you handle decisions and how you emotionally experience the investing journey. These traits are remarkably stable. You cannot change them, but you can design better structures around them.

At Oxford Risk, we measure many such traits, but five appear especially often in shaping investor behaviour. Consider these as examples:

• Risk tolerance: your reasoned willingness to accept long-term investment risk.
• Composure: how strongly you feel the emotional ups and downs of markets.
• Confidence: how capable you feel making financial decisions.
• Impulsivity: how likely you are to act quickly on emotional instinct.
• Desire for guidance: how much reassurance or partnership you prefer in decision-making.

A full profile includes several more; the financial personality assessment (link is below) can reveal a fuller picture.

The key idea is simple: in investing, who you are shapes what you do. And what you do shapes your outcomes.

The composure dilemma

One of the clearest demonstrations of personality in action is composure. It plays a far larger role in investor behaviour than most people realise. And importantly, both low and high composure come with distinct costs.

Low composure investors feel market turbulence acutely. Losses are not numbers on a screen; they are physical sensations. When anxiety rises above their emotional capacity, they seek relief – often by selling at the worst possible moment or hesitating to re-enter the market until much later. Their behaviour gap comes from emotional discomfort.

But high composure investors face a different problem entirely. They feel too calm. Because nothing feels urgent, essential portfolio housekeeping slips. Rebalancing is delayed. Reviews get postponed. Investments accumulate over time into an incoherent collection – bought at different stages of life, no longer aligned with goals, and drifting away from the right level of risk. These investors aren’t careless. They are simply too blasé to be good stewards of their wealth. Their behaviour gap comes from benign neglect.

Same markets. Same information. Completely different mistakes – all driven by personality.

This is why there is no “right” place to be on any of these personality scales. What matters is knowing where you sit and building the proper supports around yourself.

Why self-knowledge is the real advantage

Most people assume that if they only knew more, or tried harder, or forced themselves to “be braver”, investing would feel different. But investing doesn’t feel the way it does because you are doing it wrong; it feels the way it does because you are human.

Once you understand your financial personality, three things shift.

First, you stop trying to follow strategies that work for other people but feel uncomfortable for you. You can design a plan that fits your emotional reality, not someone else’s.

Second, you begin to anticipate your blind spots. Whether it’s fear, overconfidence, hesitation or impulsivity, you start seeing the pattern before it becomes a mistake.

Third, you can shape your decision environment. You put in place rules, routines, automation, commitments, review cycles and even “play pots” that help you channel your personality productively.

This is the heart of behavioural finance. Not forcing yourself to become a different person but building a structure that lets you be yourself while still making good decisions.

Two investors, one market, two different journeys

Consider two investors with identical portfolios and identical long-term plans.

One has low composure. When markets fall, they feel the weight immediately. Even though their risk tolerance is high, the emotional experience of the downturn overwhelms it. They sell to regain comfort, then sit in cash too long. Their losses come from emotion.

The other has high composure, but a low desire for guidance. The fall barely registers, but they rarely review whether their portfolio still fits their actual financial circumstances. They miss rebalancing opportunities, leave old investments lingering, and carry more (or different) risk than they realise. Their losses come from neglect.

Both lose money. Both could improve dramatically through self-knowledge. And both require very different supports.

The question is not where you sit on these scales. The question is whether you know where you sit – and how well your investing approach is adapted to it.

Designing your investing environment around your personality

Once you know your personality, you can design your investing habits to compensate for your weaknesses and amplify your strengths.

If you feel every bump, you need calming routines: less frequent checking, rules to prevent panic decisions, an emergency “panic plan”, and buffers that protect emotional liquidity.

If you barely feel the bumps, you need attentional prompts: scheduled reviews, automatic rebalancing and periodic sense-checks on whether your overall wealth structure still serves your needs.

If you act too quickly, use cooling-off periods or automation to slow you down. If you hesitate, set calendar-based commitments to force momentum. If you crave involvement, set up a safe “play pot” to channel that energy without compromising long-term wealth.

These are not restrictions. They are channels. Personality is stable, but behaviour is adaptable – once you know what needs adapting.

The takeaway

The biggest improvements in investor outcomes usually come not from better products or forecasts, but from better self-understanding. When you know your financial personality, you can build an investment approach that is stable, realistic, and genuinely sustainable for you.

You stop fighting your instincts. You start designing around them. And that is how long-term investing becomes calmer, more confident, and far more successful.

Greg B Davies leads behavioural innovation at fintech Oxford Risk, developing behavioural technology to enhance financial decision-making. He holds a PhD in behavioural decision theory from Cambridge University and is co-author of ‘Behavioral Investment Management’.

If you’d like to explore your own financial personality, you can click on this link to try a version of Oxford Risk’s financial personality assessment.

And if you want to dive deeper into the tools that help investors build behaviourally aligned long-term plans, his CPD-accredited course The Art of Behavioural Investing – created with 42Courses and Oxford Risk – walks through the full framework behind this series.

ALSO READ:

• Roller-coaster markets: How to stay calm when everyone else is screaming
• Feelings make for terrible investment decisions
• Why smart people struggle with investing

_{Top image: Rawpixel/Currency collage.}